Medical Oncology
Physician insights on cancer treatment protocols, immunotherapy, targeted therapies, and clinical trial updates.
Recent Discussions
Do you consider MSI testing for mCRPC?
I agree that data for response to immunotherapy in MMR-deficient (dMMR) prostate cancer is limited, and we estimate the rate of dMMR in prostate cancer to be low, in the 2-3% range. Nonetheless, based on responses in other dMMR tumors, pembrolizumab is now FDA approved for all dMMR/MSI-high unresect...
When discussing immunotherapy with patients, how do you frame the conversation in a way that acknowledges the fact that many patients do not respond but allows for hope for a durable response?
There is certainly more than one way to do it. The best way depends on knowing the learning style and information preferences of your patient and then tempering information that they need to have to be informed appropriately. The Shared Decision Making [SDM] model encourages us to invite the patient...
How long after starting ADT + Abiraterone can capivasertib still be safely incorporated in patients where PTEN testing is delayed?
In the CAPItello-281 clinical trial (NCT04493853; Fizazi et al., PMID 41120017), patients were allowed to enroll with prior ADT/abiraterone therapy as long as it did not exceed 3 months. It is plausible that starting capivasertib after a longer delay might still provide additional efficacy over ADT/...
In which situations do you offer ovarian suppression with chemotherapy to prevent the development of premature menopause in premenopausal women with ER negative breast cancer?
I would consider the use of GnRHa during chemotherapy in all women that are premenopausal at breast cancer diagnosis (irrespective of age) and that are concerned about developing the side effects of early menopause. Current evidence supports its use as a standard strategy for ovarian function preser...
Would you ever consider stopping immunotherapy in a patient with metastatic melanoma after achieving a good response?
Yes, I would consider stopping immunotherapy in a patient with metastatic melanoma after achieving a good response.Data of 655 melanoma patients treated in pembrolizumab phase 1 KEYNOTE-001 study has shown 95 patients (14.5%) achieved CR after a median follow-up of 32 months. Treatment was discontin...
What neoadjuvant therapy would you choose for a post menopausal woman with ER negative, PR positive high grade node negative breast cancer?
Assuming that there is no reason to doubt the results of the hormone receptor testing, and her HER2 is negative, I would treat her the same way I would a triple-negative cancer—I would not bother to send Oncotype as it should be high with the negative ER, and I wouldn't believe it if it came back lo...
Is there a correlation between rectal cancer stage and dose response to radiotherapy?
Possibly. While some compelling data from Appelt et al. in 2013 reflected there may be a correlation between RT dose and rectal tumor response (Appelt et al., PMID 22763027), an extensive number of prospective trials examining the influence of boost doses of RT on pathologic response have produced m...
In light of promising results of hydroxychloroquine in COVID-19, should we consider using it prophylactically in cancer patients, especially if immunocompromised?
At this time, as there is no good evidence available, I would not recommend the use of hydroxycholoroquine prophylactically in cancer patients. It is unclear whether it would prevent contagion, probably not, and we still don't know if it will have any effect on the course of COVID-19. We expect ther...
Is it acceptable to treat patients with limited, asymptomatic brain metastases and EGFR-mutant NSCLC with upfront TKI?
Though some clinicians have been exploring the idea of targeted therapy for EGFR mutant brain metastases, this has been done in the absence of strong evidence. Reasons for pushing this idea are that sometimes the lesions seem to respond, and this has been seen in some single arm studies and anecdota...
How would you approach a stage 1 HR+/HER2- pre-menopausal patient <50 years old with Oncotype DX RS of 24?
All the prior comments are very reasonable. It is hard to completely exclude a small absolute benefit from chemotherapy in this group. The trial's subset analyses aren't designed to definitively answer whether ovarian suppression or direct action of the chemo led to the observed risk reduction in <5...