J. Clin. Oncol. 2008-12-01
Randomized trial of postoperative reirradiation combined with chemotherapy after salvage surgery compared with salvage surgery alone in head and neck carcinoma.
Abstract
Purpose
Full-dose reirradiation combined with chemotherapy has been shown to be feasible after salvage surgery with acceptable toxicity. The Groupe d'Etude des Tumeurs de la Tête et du Cou and Groupe d'Oncologie Radiothérapie Tête Et Cou groups performed a randomized study to assess its efficacy.
Patients and methods
Between 1999 and 2005, 130 patients with head and neck cancer were treated with salvage surgery and randomly assigned to full-dose reirradiation combined with chemotherapy (RT arm) or to observation (a "wait and see" approach; WS arm). Eligibility criteria were recurrence or a second primary tumor in a previously irradiated area, no major sequelae resulting from the first radiotherapy, good general condition, no distant metastasis, and salvage surgery with macroscopic complete resection. Patients in the RT arm received 60 Gy over 11 weeks combined with concomitant fluorouracil and hydroxyurea.
Results
Sixty-five patients were randomly assigned to each arm. There was no imbalance in the distribution of the main tumor and patients characteristics. The most serious acute toxicity in the RT arm was mucositis, attaining grade 3 or 4 in 28% of patients. At 2 years, 39% of patients in the RT arm and 10% in the WS arm experienced grade 3 or 4 late toxicity according to Radiation Therapy Oncology Group criteria (P = .06). Disease-free survival (DFS) was significantly improved in the RT arm, with a hazard ratio of 1.68 (95% CI, 1.13 to 2.50; P = .01), but overall survival (OS) was not statistically different.
Conclusion
Full-dose reirradiation combined with chemotherapy after salvage surgery significantly improved DFS, but had no significant impact on OS. An increase in both acute and late toxicity was observed.
Related Questions
How would you treat a second HPV related oropharyngeal squamous cell cancer in a patient previoulsy treated and cured of a HPV related SCC of the tonsil treated with chemoradiation?
At our institution, recurrent or second primary head and neck cancers are discussed at a multidisciplinary tumor board whenever possible. We review prior radiation records, physician's notes, and pre-treatment imaging to attempt to come to a consensus whether it is truly a second primary or perhaps ...
Under what circumstances would you consider reirradiation for a patient with recurrent previously irradiated early stage laryngeal cancer now s/p salvage laryngectomy?
This type of patient would have been allowable on the GETUG trial which randomized patients after surgical salvage to no further treatment or re-irradiation with chemotherapy. The study showed a DFS advantage, but no OS advantage. There were more deaths due to treatment in the treatment arm (5 vs 0)...
How are you approaching head and neck re-irradiation cases if the recurrent cancer has been resected but with high risk features such as ECE etc.?
These are challenging situations with no correct answer.I assume we are talking about squamous cell ca and not other histologies.There is one randomized study from Europe addressing salvage surgery and re-RT vs observation. The study was conducted from 1999-2005 so much of the RT techniques and deli...