Mednet Logo

How do you select which patients with H&N primary tumors benefit from proton therapy?

This question is part of our collaboration with ASTRO 2025 to highlight impactful trial data from this year's meeting. This question is inspired by the Plenary Session Presentation "Primary Results for the Phase III Trial of Toxicity Reduction using Proton Beam Therapy for Oropharyngeal Cancer (TORPEdO; CRUK/18/010)" by Dr. David Thomson.
6 Answers
Mednet Member
Mednet Member
Radiation Oncology · Michigan Healthcare Professionals, PC
Answered on · Updated on

Surprising to see that the expert opinion after TORPEdO results is that IMPT is also a great choice. Granted, it contradicts the MDACC-led study, but we should have nuance and critical analyses.

The rates of feeding tube dependence in the IMRT arm in the MDACC-led study are astronomical. I have neve...

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer

Mednet Member
Mednet MemberInvited Expert
Radiation Oncology · Mayo Clinic
Answered on
The selection of the appropriate patient for proton therapy is not limited to anatomy and geometry, and a holistic perspective is needed. While the larger debate about the role of proton therapy in radiation oncology is often centered on late effects, there is considerable and somewhat unique intere...

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer

Mednet Member
Mednet Member
Radiation Oncology · University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center
Answered on

Selection for treatment with proton therapy for patients with head and neck tumors should be considered when a dosimetric advantage exists that can improve the clinical outcomes in head and neck cancer patients. The dosimetric differences between the two radiation modalities in the oral cavity, brai...

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer

Mednet Member
Mednet MemberInvited Expert
Radiation Oncology · Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center
Answered on

NCCN has great guidelines.

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer

Mednet Member
Mednet Member
Radiation Oncology · Michigan Healthcare Professionals, PC
Answered on

Well, what insurance does the patient have?

Joking aside, this is very important as the prices are quite high and vary from 5-10x by center, as noted in a timely article by Prasad et al., PRO 2022.

"List prices for PT differ dramatically between institutions and regions without obvious explanation, ...

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer

Mednet Member
Mednet MemberInvited Expert
Radiation Oncology · University of Florida
Answered on

Paranasal sinus, nasopharynx, oropharynx, skin with symptomatic V1 and V2 invasion, plus the occasional oral cavity.

Join for free or sign in to see the full answer