Lancet Oncol. 2014-04-01
4 Gy versus 24 Gy radiotherapy for patients with indolent lymphoma (FORT): a randomised phase 3 non-inferiority trial.
Abstract
Background
Follicular lymphoma has been shown to be highly radiosensitive with responses to doses as low as 4 Gy in two fractions. This trial was designed to explore the dose response for follicular lymphoma comparing 4 Gy in two fractions with 24 Gy in 12 fractions
Methods
FORT is a prospective randomised, unblinded, phase 3 non-inferiority study comparing radiotherapy given as 4 Gy in two fractions with a standard dose of 24 Gy in 12 fractions. Entry criteria included all patients aged over 18 years, having local radiotherapy for radical or palliative local control, with follicular lymphoma or marginal zone lymphoma, who had received no previous treatment for at least 1 month before. The primary outcome was time to local progression analysed on an intention-to-treat basis. Randomisation was centralised through the Cancer Research UK and University College London Cancer Trials Centre. Radiotherapy target sites were randomised (1:1) with minimisation stratified by histology (follicular lymphoma vs marginal zone lymphoma), treatment intent (palliative or curative) and centre. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00310167.
Findings
299 sites were randomly assigned to 24 Gy and 315 sites to 4 Gy between April 7, 2006, and June 8, 2011, at 43 centres in the UK. After a median follow-up of 26 months (range 0·39-75·4), 91 local progressions had been recorded (21 in the 24 Gy group and 70 in the 4 Gy group). Time to local progression with 4 Gy was not non-inferior to 24 Gy (hazard ratio 3·42, 95% CI 2·09-5·55, p<0·0001). Eight (3%) of 282 patients in the 24 Gy group and four (1%) of 300 in the 4 Gy group had acute grade 3-4 toxic effects. Four (1%) patients in the 24 Gy group and four (1%) patients in the 4 Gy group had late toxic effects. Mucositis was the most common event in the 24 Gy group (two patients with acute mucositis and two with late mucositis; all grade 3) and was not reported in the 4 Gy group. The most common acute effect was pain at the site of irradiation (two patients in the 4 Gy group, one patient in the 24 Gy group; all grade 3), and the most common late effect was fatigue (two patients in the 4 Gy group, one patient in the 24 Gy group; all grade 3).
Interpretation
24 Gy in 12 fractions is the more effective radiation schedule for indolent lymphoma and should be regarded as the standard of care. However, 4 Gy remains a useful alternative for palliative treatment.
Funding
Cancer Research UK.
Related Questions
For biopsy proven extranodal marginal zone lymphoma involving two small bilateral lung nodules, would you consider definitive treatment to both nodules with radiation therapy?
It has been observed that many patients treated with radiation therapy for an extranodal MZL in a paired organ (orbital and parotid, in particular) will develop metachronous disease recurrence in the contralateral organ (Goda et al., PMID 20564130). In fact, it is relatively common for patients with...
How would you manage a symptomatic marginal zone lymphoma of the base of tongue causing globus sensation also incidentally found to have squamous cell carcinoma in situ?
I would not irradiate a Stage 0 oropharyngeal cancer, much less irradiate the necks electively. But this is not just a CIS (TisN0M0 of the base of tongue) case; this is a very interesting/rare case presentation of what strikes me as a kind of Waldeyer's ring "MALToma" of the lingual tonsils. MALToma...
Is 2 Gy x 2 (or the "boom boom" regimen) appropriate for treating patients with low volume stage I MALT lymphoma?
I disagree. My answer is no. The quoted series contains very few patients with short follow-up. I am not aware of any large series with long follow-up of MALT pts with early stage disease treated with curative intent in this fashion. A randomized trial of 2gy x 2 for early-stage follicular lymphoma ...
How would you approach a fit older (>70 years) with grade I-II, bulky, follicular lymphoma causing ureteral obstruction and renal failure?
You could also consider focal radiotherapy as we know follicular lymphoma is often very radiosensitive (and can respond quickly to RT). Depending on the trajectory of the AKI and dysfunction, I would discuss with my urology colleagues to see if there is any role for ureteral stenting to see if kidne...
What is the appropriate RT dose for an advanced stage follicular lymphoma?
Based on the study for patients of early stage low grade lymphoma treated with curative intent, the dose should be 24 Gy.For those treated with palliative intent, 2gy x2 should be preferred, as the majority have good palliation with that dose. In the minority where symptoms persists, one can treat a...