JAMA 2016-07-26
Effect of Radiosurgery Alone vs Radiosurgery With Whole Brain Radiation Therapy on Cognitive Function in Patients With 1 to 3 Brain Metastases: A Randomized Clinical Trial.
Abstract
Importance
Whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT) significantly improves tumor control in the brain after stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), yet because of its association with cognitive decline, its role in the treatment of patients with brain metastases remains controversial.
Objective
To determine whether there is less cognitive deterioration at 3 months after SRS alone vs SRS plus WBRT.
Design, setting, and participants
At 34 institutions in North America, patients with 1 to 3 brain metastases were randomized to receive SRS or SRS plus WBRT between February 2002 and December 2013.
Interventions
The WBRT dose schedule was 30 Gy in 12 fractions; the SRS dose was 18 to 22 Gy in the SRS plus WBRT group and 20 to 24 Gy for SRS alone.
Main outcomes and measures
The primary end point was cognitive deterioration (decline >1 SD from baseline on at least 1 cognitive test at 3 months) in participants who completed the baseline and 3-month assessments. Secondary end points included time to intracranial failure, quality of life, functional independence, long-term cognitive status, and overall survival.
Results
There were 213 randomized participants (SRS alone, n = 111; SRS plus WBRT, n = 102) with a mean age of 60.6 years (SD, 10.5 years); 103 (48%) were women. There was less cognitive deterioration at 3 months after SRS alone (40/63 patients [63.5%]) than when combined with WBRT (44/48 patients [91.7%]; difference, -28.2%; 90% CI, -41.9% to -14.4%; P < .001). Quality of life was higher at 3 months with SRS alone, including overall quality of life (mean change from baseline, -0.1 vs -12.0 points; mean difference, 11.9; 95% CI, 4.8-19.0 points; P = .001). Time to intracranial failure was significantly shorter for SRS alone compared with SRS plus WBRT (hazard ratio, 3.6; 95% CI, 2.2-5.9; P < .001). There was no significant difference in functional independence at 3 months between the treatment groups (mean change from baseline, -1.5 points for SRS alone vs -4.2 points for SRS plus WBRT; mean difference, 2.7 points; 95% CI, -2.0 to 7.4 points; P = .26). Median overall survival was 10.4 months for SRS alone and 7.4 months for SRS plus WBRT (hazard ratio, 1.02; 95% CI, 0.75-1.38; P = .92). For long-term survivors, the incidence of cognitive deterioration was less after SRS alone at 3 months (5/11 [45.5%] vs 16/17 [94.1%]; difference, -48.7%; 95% CI, -87.6% to -9.7%; P = .007) and at 12 months (6/10 [60%] vs 17/18 [94.4%]; difference, -34.4%; 95% CI, -74.4% to 5.5%; P = .04).
Conclusions and relevance
Among patients with 1 to 3 brain metastases, the use of SRS alone, compared with SRS combined with WBRT, resulted in less cognitive deterioration at 3 months. In the absence of a difference in overall survival, these findings suggest that for patients with 1 to 3 brain metastases amenable to radiosurgery, SRS alone may be a preferred strategy.
Trial registration
clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00377156.
Related Questions
In light of Aizer et al. data presented at ASCO 2025, what is your threshold for offering SRS/SRT in patients with multiple brain metastases?
Over the past 4 decades, the treatment of brain metastases has been evolving along with advances in technology, from simple whole brain radiation (WBRT) with opposed lateral fields to IMRT-driven treatment (HA-WBRT); similarly, in the field of SRS/SRT, we have pushed the envelope of what we can achi...
How do you counsel patients on the neurocognitive effects of whole brain radiation therapy?
This answer was co-authored with @Dr. First LastThank you for the opportunity to address this important and increasingly complex question. Part of the complexity inherent to this question revolves around the rapidly evolving advances that our field has made in delivering safer brain metastasis treat...
Do you ever withhold PCI for elderly patients with limited stage SCLC?
In my opinion, the findings by Takahashi et al, Lancet 2017 regarding the lack of survival benefit of PCI as compared to MRI observation in patients with extensive SCLC has re-opened the question of the survival benefit of PCI in limited SCLC in the modern imaging era. Hopefully, a phase III study o...
Is there any role for SRS+WBRT for patients with a limited number of small brain metastases?
The recent publication from Dr Brown confirmed the finding from prior studies, that omitting upfront whole brain RT doesn't compromise OS in patients with limited brain metastases. More importantly, this second study had neurocognition as the primary end point, and confirmed better neurocognition pr...
Is it acceptable to treat newly diagnosed small cell lung cancer with limited brain metastasis with upfront SRS?
First, to be clear, there's not good evidence regarding the role of radiosurgery in small cell patients who have not had WBRT or PCI. In patients without brain metastases, there's a clearly defined and clinically significant survival benefit, which seems to result from both control of existing metas...